Calderwood Translation on Easter

In light of Easter coming up, we have translated a classic section from the Scottish presbyterian minister, David Calderwood, on this addition to God’s worship.

The observation of Easter was claimed to be indifferent by Scottish prelates (as it is often so claimed to be today by reformed ministers), it being imposed at the Perth Assembly in Scotland in 1618.  In 1623, Calderwood laid out these propositions in Latin on indifferent things and ceremonies about God’s worship, which precisely delineate the Biblical and classical presbyterian view on the subject.

As such, these propositions are timeless.  Please enjoy them and share them with your friends, and remember to keep the Lord’s Day holy.

Calderwood, David – ‘Propositions on Indifferent Things & Ceremonies in Worship’  trans. T. Fentiman  (1623; RBO, 2021)

A New Translation of Rollock

There is a short tract in Latin on God’s decree of predestination by Robert Rollock, the early and formative Scottish theologian, which was left untranslated in his two volume Select Works.  It has now been translated and made publicly available for the first time.

Rollock here treats of the important distinctions to be recognized within God’s decree of predestination, especially as it comes to be variously executed through time in providence.  Of special interest is his formulations relating to what would be later known as the sincere free offer of the Gospel:

“Approval without the decree belongs to all good things with respect to themselves, though they are not at any time realized, of which sort are the conversion, faith, and salvation of reprobates; which God surely approves of simply, but does not decree to come about…  1 Tim. 2:4, ‘Who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth.’”

Rollock’s early paradigm appears to have been influential through later reformed thought as reflections of it occur in later reformed scholastics, including in the Metaphysical Disquisitions of Samuel Rutherford at the end of his Latin treatise on Providence.

Treat yourself to some of the best reformed theology extant:

Rollock, Robert – A Brief Instruction on the Eternal Approval & Disapproval of the Divine Mind  1593/4  6 pp.  trans. Charles Johnson & Travis Fentiman

New Translation from Rutherford

For the first time, here is over a hundred pages translated into English from Rutherford’s Examination of Arminianism in Latin, for free and online.

Rutherford’s Examination was the closest thing he wrote to systematic theology.  As Arminians erred on nearly every point of theology, refuting their rising, popular system gave Rutherford the opportunity to survey nearly the whole gamut of theology.  Rutherford addresses topics here nowhere addressed in his books written in English.

The level of depth, detail and Scriptural, theological accuracy in this work far surpasses nearly anything available in English today.  Learn theology from the greatest Scottish theologian in Church history.

Rutherford, Samuel – Rutherford’s Examination of Arminianism: the Tables of Contents with Excerpts from Every Chapter  trans. Charles Johnson & Travis Fentiman  1668 / 2019  135 pp.

The History of Scottish Worship

It was said of the Scottish reformers: “The ministers that were took not their pattern from any Kirk [Church] in the world… but, laying God’s Word before them, made reformation according thereunto…” (John Row, 1637)

It is no exaggeration to say that the worship of God from the Scottish Reformation is the most important in Church history, it being the most closely aligned according to Scripture.

Here is a treasure of resources on the history of Scottish worship that will provide a plethora of information on every aspect of it, in every era.

The History of Scottish Worship

The Marrow Controversy

The Marrow Controversy in early-1700’s Scotland hinged on the the warrant of the Free Offer of the Gospel displaying God’s grace and good-will to gospel-hearers.

Mature your understanding of the Christian faith in looking into this important and intriguing historical controversy.  Here are the most resources on the net about it.

As for us, we are Marrow men.  On this Lord’s Day, take up and read a sermon by one of the original Marrow Men, Thomas Boston, Ralph Erskine or Ebenezer Erskine, and delight your soul in these refreshing Gospel-waters,

The Marrow Controversy 

Scottish Church History

The Scottish Church for centuries held the standard for reformed Christianity.  Her history is the most important, the most exciting and the best to learn from.

For beginners and scholars alike, here is a massive collection of resources on Scottish Church history, organized by the time period. 

Apart from researching a dissertation, it will probably have everything you need to answer just about every question you may have about Scottish Church history.  Here is the treasure of the public domain (and more) on the topic.

Scottish Church History

We hope it is a blessing to you.

Theological Writings from Scottish Church History

We make no apology that Scottish Church history is more important than any other strand of Church history.

Consequently, we have collected many of the theological tracts from the Resolutioner-Protester controversy of the 1650’s so that you can read them first-hand.  The webpage contains an introduction to the era and issues, as well as valuable historical materials on it.

The Scottish Resolutioner-Protester Controversy, 1650’s

Likewise, there really has been no collection available of the defenses of covenanting and literature surrounding the indulgence controversy, during 1660-1688, until now.  The most fascinating aspect of this literature, besides that of defending civil resistance from Scripture and natural law, is the debate over Church unity and degrees of separation.

Defenses of Scottish Covenanting and the Indulgence Controversy, 1661-1688

May these resources be a blessing to you, and may God’s name be hallowed.

Rutherford’s Due Right of Presbyteries

What is the definitive work in Church history arguing and delineating classic presbyterianism?

Samuel Rutherford’s The Due Right of Presbyteries.  Rutherford answers every detailed point of ecclesiology (things about the Church) that you ever thought of, and many, many more.

The problem, though, is that this is one of the most dis-organized books there is.  So, we have made an outline, table of contents and subject index to it in contemporary format, with links to corresponding page numbers, so that you can easily find where he treats of interesting subjects.

For those more skilled in historical theology, see if you can find the two dozen points where modern presbyterianism departs from classically defined, historic, presbyterianism from the Church of Scotland during the Westminster era.

Please enjoy:

“Samuel Rutherford’s The Due Right of Presbyteries: Table of Contents and Subject Index”  1644  22 pp.  ed. Travis Fentiman

Gillespie on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom

Is Christ’s Kingdom as the Mediator the Church only, or does it include all things?

George Gillespie, the Westminster divine and Scottish covenanter has the most in-depth writings on the majority puritan view that Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church only.

Gillespie’s material, the most in-depth on the topic, has often not been read due to its inaccessibility.  The Reformed Presbyterians, as a family of denominations, officially take the opposite viewpoint.  Often their view is put forward as a self-evidently correct interpretation of the relevant texts.

This collection of Gillespie’s writings in contemporary format, with explanatory notes, will shed a lot more light on the issues and the details of the relevant Scriptural texts.

As a bonus, these writings of Gillespie are also the classic delineation of the Establishment Principle, the Biblical relation between Church and State.

May this document be a rich and helpful resource to you in further searching out the things of God and Biblical doctrine.

George Gillespie – ‘All of Gillespie’s Writings on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church Only’  110 pp.  ed. Travis Fentiman

Rutherford’s Treatise on Providence: the Table of Contents in English

Rutherford tackles some of the hardest topics in theology in his Latin treatise on Providence, which has never been translated before.  For the first time, peer into this intriguing and important work which seeks to keep the straight line, not departing into the errors on either side, of God’s mysterious ways with us.

Samuel Rutherford’s Treatise on Providence: the Table of Contents in English  2016  7 pp.

Rutherford on the Judicial Laws

How do the Judicial Laws of Moses apply today to our civil politics?  There are two extremes:

– Christian evangelicalism which accepts pluralism and finds no use for the divinely given pattern revealed in Moses, and

– Theonomy which says that the Judicial Laws of Moses are as binding, in exhaustive detail, as they ever were.

There is another choice, though: the historic, majority Reformed view that the Judicial Law as a category has expired, except as its General Equity (Moral Principles) continue to bind today.

Samuel Rutherford expounds and illustrates the viewpoint of the Westminster Confession.  Let Rutherford take you to school and teach you what General Equity Biblically, and has historically, entailed:

Samuel Rutherford on the Judicial Laws of Moses: Excerpts Arranged Topically  32 pp.

All of the Commentaries of the Scottish Covenanters

Previously we had posted all of the commentaries on a whole book of the Bible by the Scottish covenanters in English (25 entries).  We came to feel that this was not enough.  So we decided to collect all of the English commentaries and series of sermons on anything the length of one Bible chapter or more by the covenanters (plus a few more).  

There are now 2.5 times as many entries as there were before (61 in all), for your reading pleasure, including many gems that may otherwise go unnoticed.  Please enjoy:

All of the Bible Commentaries of the Scottish Covenanters in English

All of the Writings of the Scottish Covenanters

Why read the Scottish Covenanters?

Because it is in fire that gold glows the brightest and most purely, and God, in his infinite wisdom, graced the Scottish covenanters with some of the hottest fires that Church history has ever seen.  It is when the fire is stoked seven times hotter than ever that one like unto the Son of God has been known to appear with his beloved people in their midst (Dan. 3:19,24-25).  

Immanuel has  promised to be with us in the valley of the shadow of death, and it is there, in the midst of enemies, that He prepares a table for us and causes our cup to run over (Ps. 23:4-5).  As Samuel Rutherford said, it is in the bottom cellar of affliction in God’s House where God keeps his choicest wine.  Come, taste and drink these old, fragrant wines at no cost (Isa. 55:1-2):

All of the Writings of the Scottish Covenanters

All of the Bible Commentaries of the Scottish Covenanters

The Scottish covenanters (1560-1689) wrote some of the most solid and spiritually savory Bible commentaries that history has graced to us.  Here are all of them, most of which can be read for free on the net.  For the others, use your tax-refund (for those who haven’t done their taxes yet).  Charles Spurgeon’s comments annotate the list (don’t miss them).  Of these refreshing wells, drink deeply and oft:

All of the Bible Commentaries of the Scottish Covenanters

The Scottish Covenants on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church Only

It is often claimed, and widely believed, that the Scottish covenants of the Westminster era and the 1600’s, and the Scottish covenanters generally, taught that Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is over all things and that Christ is the Head of the civil magistrate.  The Solemn League and Covenant (1643) is often held up as a banner for this doctrine.

Unfortunately these claims are historically false.  Not only does the Solemn League and Covenant not teach this, neither do any of the documents from Scotland’s better days.  Here is the exhaustive documentation:

All of the Scottish Confessions, Covenants and Declarations from the Scottish Reformation, Puritan and Covenanting Eras on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church Only

Gillespie on the Origins of Christ’s Two Kingdoms

George Gillespie, the Westminster divine, relates the historical origins of the scriptural recognition and elucidation of the doctrine of Christ’s Two Kingdoms in the early Church and the Reformation.  It is slightly fascinating.  Your appreciation for historical theology is about to increase:

Gillespie on the Early Church and Reformation Origins of Christ’s Two Kingdoms

 

Adam Gib on the Free Offer

This is the best piece that Christian history has bequeathed to us on God’s Call in the Gospel Offer in relation to the Atonement.  Read it, and you will agree.  This may be the most important theological piece ReformedBooksOnline has published yet.  Gib (d. 1788) was a minister in the Scottish Secession Church.  Here he opens the door to God’s House of Mercy.

Concerning the Gospel Call and the Warrant of Faith  1747, 31 pages, from his The Present Truth: A Display of the Secession Testimony, vol. 2, Progression 5

 

 

James Durham on the Free Offer

Dr. Donald MacLean’s recent dissertation on James Durham and the Free Offer is now (largely) online and available for purchase.  Please enjoy! 

Maclean, Donald – James Durham (1622-1658) and the Gospel Offer in its Seventeenth Century Context  Buy  2015  311 pp.   

‘The free offer of the gospel has been a matter of significant debate within Reformed theology. However, despite this controversy, Reformed theologians such as James Durham preached a gospel offer which was a sincere and free invitation from God to all, to embrace Jesus Christ as Saviour. This gospel offer expressed God’s grace and goodness to all. Donald MacLean argues that Durham’s doctrinal position is representative of the Westminster Standards and embraced by his contemporaries and evidenced by the later disputes concerning the meaning of the teaching of the Westminster Confession of Faith.’

‘It is impossible to avoid the conclusion that Durham (1622-1658) teaches that God desires the salvation of all men.’

John Brown of Haddington on the Sincere Free Offer

It is often little known how common (universal almost) that the doctrine of the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel has been in reformed history.  So here is it is documented in another major reformed figure, of whom the world was not worthy.  Brown was an early 1700’s Scotsman who learned Greek on his own as a shepherd in the fields while he was young man, became a theological professor in the Secession Church, and is most well known today for his Systematic Theology (or, Natural and Revealed Religion, as it was originally published).

John Brown of Haddington on the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel