On Voting

The Lord comes before all, even in who we vote for in political elections.  His priorities ought to be our priorities.

Yet does this mean one should only vote for a Christian candidate “publicly committed to scriptural principles of civil government,” or not vote at all?  That is a main thesis of an RPCNA booklet, Christ Centered Voting.

Travis Fentiman, MDiv, the webmaster, has written 64 Theses on the Ethics of Civil Voting where he shows that the above limitation is contrary to Scripture and defends the due extent of God-glorifying voting according to the will of God for the purpose of making further reformation in our land.

Whatever your perspective is now, the theses will be challenging to you.  May iron sharpen iron and cause us to grow in the knowledge of the Lord’s things, that we may be faithful to Him even in the matter of voting.

On Voting

The Civil Government’s Authority about the Church

The Reformation and puritan era’s teaching on the Church-State relationship, derived from the Word of God in accord with the light of Nature, has been all but lost today.  The term for it was circa sacra; it means that the magistrate has authority, not in, but ‘around the sacred aspects’ of religion and the Church.

While the civil government does not have formal authority over the Church, as Christ is her only Head, yet the magistrate does have civil authority over the material Church in legitimate civil matters that pertain equally in principle to civil society.

As all people are to seek first the Kingdom of God with the natural power they have (Mt. 6:33), so likewise the civil government ought to use its natural, God-given, civil power for the good of Christ’s Kingdom, the Church (Isa. 49:23; 60:10,12,16), including in civilly professing, protecting and promoting the True Religion, and civilly establishing it in the land.

We need to reform ourselves and our nations to the Word of God.  This newly written Extended Introduction to circa sacra outlines in detail the older view of the original Westminster Confession (1646) and reformed orthodoxy, and is a gateway into puritan literature on the subject.  The paper also explains the differences between the Reformation view of circa sacra and the later ‘Establishment Principle’ of the 1800’s Free Church of Scotland.

Appended to the work is a section from the London presbyterian ministers’ Divine Right of Church Government (1646) on circa sacra: the most readable, systematic and brief setting forth of the older view of circa sacra (with most of its numerous necessary distinctions) from the Scriptures in English that the webmaster is aware of.

Take the time to build your life on solid doctrine.

Fentiman, Travis & London Presbyterians – The Civil Government’s Authority about Religion & the Church, Circa Sacra:  An Extended Introduction & a Section from the English Presbyterians’ Divine Right  (1646; ReformedBooksOnline, 2021)  123 pp.

.

“Be wise now therefore, O ye kings:
be instructed, ye judges of the earth.
Serve the Lord with fear, and rejoice with trembling.”

Ps. 2:10-11

How Far the Church may Speak to Civil Issues

From Covid regulations to getting Woke with social justice and activism, this could not be a more needful question to have accurate, Biblical and solid answers to.  One ‘conservative’ reaction to the politicizing of the Church, in contrast also to the later full-blown liberal, social gospel, was the 1800’s, American, Southern presbyterian doctrine of the ‘spirituality of the Church’, which in fact was a reduction of preaching the whole counsel of God.  Today a similar mindset is held by much of fundamentalist baptist America, following in line with the Pietist and Anabaptist traditions.

Turn, however, to the Reformation and puritan eras, not because of the stature of those men, but because you will find that they hammered out this topic in more precise and accurate detail faithful to the Word of God than any other era in history.  The Rock of God’s Word does not move or change.

Find the Truth, and be steadfast in it for the rest of your life.  Start with Gillespie, who concisely outlines the puritan doctrine, reformed accoring to the Word of God, and take every thought captive to the obedience of Christ.

How Far the Church May Speak to Civil Issues

On Political Theology

How can politics be reformed according to the Word of God?  Christians more than ever need to gain a more thorough understanding of what Christianity says about politics and law.  To say that political theology has been neglected in modern times is an understatement.

We have collected all of the webpages related to political theology on ReformedBooksOnline onto one page:

On Political Theology

On Jurisprudence

Rulers are to rule in equity (Ps. 99:4; Prov. 17:26).  While even the humblest believer can recognize the rightness or wrongness of a case laid before him (1 Cor. 6), yet we are to exercise our senses in order to be able to discern good and evil in greater maturity (Heb. 5:14), especially as we are called to as mothers and fathers, elders and those who hold offices in business or the civil government.

History has bequeathed to us an extensive and profound collection of writings elaborating on what constitutes equity according to Natural Law.  This is a field in which believers can learn a lot in from natural men.

Many books of Church order are surprisingly sparse with respect to guidance in many particulars.  Rather than making things up as one goes, expand your awareness of the principles of equity and justice:

On Jurisprudence

Specifically, we have been happily surprised with how much profit, spiritual as well as natural, we have found in collections of Legal Maxims.

.

“He loveth righteousness and judgment…”

Ps. 33:5

How does One Distinguish Between Legitimate & Illegitimate Authority?

Authority is not well understood by Christian people today.  For some it means, ‘You are required to obey what we determine.’  Right authority, however, is, ‘You are required to obey what God has determined.’

Many people can recognize authorities arbitrarily tyrannizing.  But that is only a negative recognition.  What is the positive side that characterizes, and is requisite for all legitimate authority?

Learn the Scriptural answer from our reformed forefathers, and let it re-form you, deeply:

That the Mere Will, Determination, Judgment or Saying So of Authorities is an Insufficient Ground of Faith & Obedience, & that Authorities are Never to Act or Require Something without a Naturally, Morally or Spiritually Sufficient Reason, & that Manifest to Consciences

May the Magistrate Forbid Church Assemblies in a Time of a Severe, Spreading Disease?

May the Magistrate rightly quarantine and restrain assemblies, including those of the Church, upon sufficient natural and civil warrant?

Rutherford’s answer to that question was ‘Yes’, along with other reformed figures in that era, including the civil government of the Netherlands during the time of the Synod of Dort (1619).

The Reformation, Puritan and presbyterian doctrine, that the Church is subject to the Magistrate in legitimate civil laws and matters circa sacra (around the sacred) is evidenced even in our own day by civil governments (rightly) enforcing fire codes, zoning laws and sound ordinances, etc. upon churches.

See many theological points related to this topic documented from the Reformation and puritan eras, especially from Gillespie and Rutherford, on this new page:

On the Civil Magistrate’s Just Authority for Restraining the Congregating of Citizens, even the Church, and Quarantining, etc., with Sufficient Natural Warrant, according to God’s Moral Law

(The page does not address every issue that ought to be considered in relation to the current response to the Corona virus, such as, what churches should do if the magistrate does not have sufficient natural and moral warrant to forbid their assembly.)

The Establishment Principle in the American Westminster Standards

The view on the relation between Church and State during the Reformation and the Westminster Assembly was the Establishment Principle, that the State is to uphold all of the 10 Commandments and to profess, protect, promote and civilly establish the True Religion (circa sacra).

It is commonly thought that the American revisions of the Westminster documents removed the Establishment Principle from them.  This is not the case.

As is documented in detail in this article, the American Westminster Standards teach that the civil magistrate is to establish the Christian religion in the land, albeit a general, non-denominational Christianity.

See for yourself what your presbyterian church officers have vowed to teach and uphold.  And more than this, come into a greater acquaintance with what the Word of God teaches about Church-State relations.

The Establishment Principle in the American Westminster Standards and Early American States

Constitutionalism

A Church’s constitution, subordinate to the Word of God, defines its being and public testimony.

Officers’ vows define the officers’ relationship to the Church and obligates them to uphold the Church’s constitution, as opposed to undermining it.  The constitution serves as a legal security to minorities who seek to uphold the acknowledged principles of the Church.  A change in the constitution, apart from the lawful process thereto, effectively breaks the terms of union by which persons are bound to the Church.

Learn more about the principles of Constitutionalism here, with the most mature, balanced and developed resources on the topic from Church history.

Here is much needed health for the Church today.

Constitutionalism

The General Equity of the Judicial Law

Wherever there is a vacuum of sound, Biblical teaching, errors breed and multiply as sincere Christians try to reinvent a doctrinal wheel from Scripture.  

There has for a long time been a nearly complete silence in American Christianity (Reformed included) on what the general equity of the Old Testament Judicial Law entails.  In its place has crept in the polar alternatives of status-quo, civilly protected polytheism (of the Book of Judges and American tradition) and Mosaic Theonomy.  

Fortunately, that vacuum has officially now ended.  Learn why the Biblical and majority view of the Reformation and Puritan eras on General Equity is right:

The General Equity of the Old Testament Civil Laws

As the faithful Church is the pillar and ground of the truth (1 Tim. 3:15), it is never safe to take a minority view of something in Scripture until you, at least, know all of the reasons for the majority view.  May we seek to reform according to the Word of God as we learn from godlier and more knowledgeable saints of old than we.

The Scottish Covenants on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church Only

It is often claimed, and widely believed, that the Scottish covenants of the Westminster era and the 1600’s, and the Scottish covenanters generally, taught that Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is over all things and that Christ is the Head of the civil magistrate.  The Solemn League and Covenant (1643) is often held up as a banner for this doctrine.

Unfortunately these claims are historically false.  Not only does the Solemn League and Covenant not teach this, neither do any of the documents from Scotland’s better days.  Here is the exhaustive documentation:

All of the Scottish Confessions, Covenants and Declarations from the Scottish Reformation, Puritan and Covenanting Eras on Christ’s Mediatorial Kingdom is the Church Only

Against Separation from Impure Civil Governments

If our civil government is not Christian, has many impurities and corruptions in it, and is driven by ungodly rulers, are we able to wholesale write-off its authority, or are we to obey it as unto the Lord in their lawful injunctions?

Inform yourself of the majority, historic reformed, and Westminster viewpoint, and may it cause us to walk with greater circumspection in the fear and holiness of God.

Against Separation from Impure Civil Governments