Children attending Congregational Worship

Some teach the Bible obligates infants and young children to attend congregational worship.  This new in-depth article by Fentiman shows:

‘There is No Divine Obligation for Infants or Young Children to Regularly attend an Adult Worship Service’

All the Old Testament evidence respecting young children at public worship concerns extraordinary circumstances. There was no Scriptural rule young children had to attend the Tabernacle, Temple or synagogue.

All the New Testament evidence (see for yourself) does not equate to young children sitting quietly for an hour and a half (or longer) every Lord’s Day (or twice thereon) without a break.

A fuller survey of Church history is given than what has been elsewhere documented, showing that much of it did not require children to attend public worship till seven or eight years old, or till puberty (around 13), often for the reasons of human growth and development.  Some, including Scottish covenanters, prohibited younger children from attending.  Westminster is analyzed in detail, showing it is open on the issue.

Children’s church and Sunday school is also theologically analyzed, showing these may be consistent with the Regulative Principle of Worship and the Westminster standards.

This is not intended to discourage moderate parenting of young children in congregational worship, but is only contrary to that which is immoderate or is made a religious requirement.  Practical choices in the matter ought to be guided by nature’s light, Christian prudence and the Word’s general rules (WCF 1.6), unto edification, which things can be variable.

For those that love the truth.

.

“When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things.”

1 Cor. 13:11

On Impurities in Worship

We ought to love God’s worship, but what about when we face impurities in it?  Questions abound: Ought one to abstain from every impurity, or may some be participated in?  Must one separate from the whole service? (No)

Our new page goes indepth into these questions and many more, answering them from the Scriptures, Westminster and the puritans.

Some churches teach, “Sincerity cannot make unscriptural worship acceptable to God.”  This is plainly contrary to the Word (1 Kings 8:18-19; 22:42-43; 2 Kings 12:2-3; 2 Chron. 15:15-18; Ps. 51:17; Rom. 14:1-8, etc.), Westminster and the puritans, as is demonstrated in the webpage’s section: ‘God May Graciously Accept Impure Worship’.  A new article defends this from the account of Nadab, Abihu and Aaron in Lev. 10.

Other sections distinguish between impurities and literal idolatry, that impure worship ordinances may be valid, that we have necessary duties in worship though others sin, and that some impurities may be, and may need to be, personally performed.  In addition, attending externally impure worship may be better than attending a church with externally purer worship, due to many circumstances and reasons.

Navigating impurities in worship can be complex, so we put together detailed principles from solid theologians on how to go about such.  The page also gives guidance on what to do when impurities cannot be reformed.

A section to be read slowly and deeply is that all worship, even of glorified saints and angels, is impure before God’s uncreated being and infinite perfections, forever.

The webpage includes an Intro to the issues (with answers):

On Impurities in Worship

Praise the Lord for so much light from our fathers on the subject, and may He lighten your path.  “The entrance of thy words giveth light; it giveth understanding unto the simple.” Ps. 119:30

What is Worship?

Some persons say all of life is worship, and see no special significance for the Church’s public worship.  Others, often in reaction, hold worship to be only worship ordinances, such as prayer, reading Scripture and singing praise, whether publicly or privately.

Both are wrong, according to Scripture and reformed orthodoxy.  Worship, narrowly speaking, is an immediate honoring of God.  Keeping God’s commandments mediately honors God, and hence is worship.  All of life is worship insofar as worship naturally and Biblically includes anything done out of reference to God.

Reform yourself to the Word and carefully consider our new page of resources, and let them sink deep into your soul:

‘On the Definition of Worship’

Likewise, some of the most fundamental and helpful distinctions about worship, filling out what it is and its nature, have been nearly wholly lost today.  Peruse these new pages:

‘On Internal & External Worship’

‘Natural vs. Instituted Worship’

Yes, internal worship is more important than external, and natural more than instituted, according to nature, Scripture (see the many Bible verses on the webpages) and reformed orthodoxy.

If you thought you knew Westminster well, get indepth theological background to what Westminster does and does not say about this subject on the Natural vs. Instituted page:

‘WCF 21.1 & its Theological Context’

Drink deeply of the Lord’s theological teachings, lay hold of all the riches you can, and send them to your friends.

.

“Worship God.”

Rev. 22:9

Head-Covering in Worship?

Is Paul’s injunction for women to cover their heads in worship binding today (1 Cor. 11:2-16)?

Most of the Reformed, the Scottish covenanters and the Westminster divines in the Reformation and puritan era said ‘No,’ that Paul’s ordinance was relative to his culture, which used this custom.

In the most detailed exegetical and theological treatment of this issue since that era, Travis Fentiman (MDiv, webmaster) argues that this view is conclusive from the Word of God, in his new book:

1 Corinthians – Head-Coverings are Not Perpetual & they were Hair-Buns, with or without Cloth Material: Proven  (RBO, 2022)  283 pp.

The book’s Intro and the Overview of the Argument following it will whet your desire to invest the time to look through the rest, from which you will reap many rewards.  To see how Corinthian women covered their heads, see the many pictures in the History section on pp. 188-98.

For a summary of the main points of the whole book, see the Summary Conclusions beginning on p. 258.  Here is the logical structure of the book’s main argument.  Every proposition is thoroughly proven in detail in the book:

1. All positive, instituted worship must be “expressly set down in Scripture” or “by good and necessary consequence… deduced” therefrom (Westminster Confession of Faith 1.6).

2. In Scripture head-coverings, or the lack thereof, bore a variety of contrary meanings and acceptability, or not, in worship.  Hence they were clearly cultural.

3. Head-coverings cannot be taught by pure-nature and have no intrinsic value for worshipping God.

4. Paul only uses the language of “dishonor,” “becometh,” “glory” and “custom” about head-coverings, which are all things of social decency, but do not reflect inherent sins.  As with head-coverings, Paul uses imperatives in 1 Cor. 7 about things not intrinsically sinful.

5. Some apostolic ordinances were circumstantially conditioned and mutable.

6. Universal moral reasons given for a practice, such as head-coverings, not eating creeping things (Lev. 11:41, 44), the holy kiss, foot-washing, etc. does not necessarily make it perpetual. A context is assumed and generals can only bind generally.

7. There is nothing in 1 Cor. 11 necessitating head-coverings to have a different meaning or use in worship than in society.

8. There is no necessary warrant Corinthian head-coverings were geographically or temporally universal in the apostolic churches; but if they were, this does not itself make an ordinance to be of positive religion, especially as the Greco-Roman culture (which head-coverings were appropriate to) was vast.

9. Part I’s survey of all the relevant Scriptural head-covering data (consider it for yourself) shows there is no express or good and necessary consequence from these texts that Corinthian head-coverings were a positive, perpetual rite of religion (WCF 21.1) beyond circumstances common to human society, ordered by nature’s light, Christian prudence and the Word’s general principles (WCF 1.6), which things may be culturally relative.

10. These things being the case, Paul’s statement that improper head-covering “dishonoreth her head,” (v. 5) must be, not prescriptive, but descriptive, as the case was in that society (which it was). Hence Paul’s natural and spiritual arguments are contingent on this de facto premise.  A change of the premise in a different culture where not covering is not dishonoring, changes the conclusion.

May We Change the Sacraments in Necessity?

In extra-ordinary circumstances where a sacrament may not be performed in the exact way that Christ prescribed, ought a church to forego the sacrament (or that part of it) or ought principled accommodations be made which keep the essential, spiritual principles of the sacrament?

In the Reformation and puritan era, the Lutherans (the Biblicists of their day) answered the former; those Churches reformed according to the Word of God: the latter.

This new page documents this in detail.  The Intro will walk you through the issues and show you from the light of God’s Word and Nature why the reformed position is right.  Add further knowledge and understanding to your faith, seeking to please Him in walking more closely according to his Will.

On the Administration of the Sacraments in Extra-Ordinary Circumstances

Praying & Worshipping Together, Apart

The Orthodox Presbyterian Chuch in America has called for today, Saturday, August 21, 2021, to be a day of prayer and fasting that “we might lament our distress and unworthiness before the Lord, confess our sin, and commit ourselves anew to the faithful service of the Lord our God…”  This could not be more appropriate and necessary for the times.

Though churches and famillies are separated by great distance and circumstances, yet the OPC has called for this “that the whole church may pray as one people, and call upon the Lord with one voice..”

This principle, that Christians who are separated by great distance and are not meeting together in one assembly, or possibly in any assembly, yet pray together, and offer to God one public worship (as opposed to each offering simply their own separate, individual worship, unconjoined to the rest), is thoroughly Scriptural and historically reformed.  When the early Church was spread throughout Jerusalem, divided by geography and walls, not being able to see each other, and Peter was in prison (the news being spread by mouth), “prayer [singular] was made without ceasing of the Church [singular] unto God for him.” (Acts 12:5)

Needless to say, the same principle is very relevant for churches still meeting online (of necessity) to publicly worship under COVID restrictions.  Grow in your knowledge of Scriptural and historic, reformed principles of worship and the mystical communion of the saints through our one Mediator in Heaven with the resources on this page:

On Holding Public Worship & Church Courts by Distance Through Technology, & on Using Satellite Churches, under Necessity & for Edification

Calderwood Translation on Easter

In light of Easter coming up, we have translated a classic section from the Scottish presbyterian minister, David Calderwood, on this addition to God’s worship.

The observation of Easter was claimed to be indifferent by Scottish prelates (as it is often so claimed to be today by reformed ministers), it being imposed at the Perth Assembly in Scotland in 1618.  In 1623, Calderwood laid out these propositions in Latin on indifferent things and ceremonies about God’s worship, which precisely delineate the Biblical and classical presbyterian view on the subject.

As such, these propositions are timeless.  Please enjoy them and share them with your friends, and remember to keep the Lord’s Day holy.

Calderwood, David – ‘Propositions on Indifferent Things & Ceremonies in Worship’  trans. T. Fentiman  (1623; RBO, 2021)

The Simplicity of Worship

Anyone who reads the book of Acts will be struck with how simple that standard of apostolic worship was, which is forever a rule to the Christian Church.

The more simple the worship is, the more spiritual it will be shown to be, when persons have nothing else to cling to in it but the Word of God laid bare, in the praying, the singing, the reading and the preaching of the Word.

The simplicity and spirituality of Christian worship, in contradistinction to most evangelical and even reformed worship today, used to be a well-known doctrine of the Reformation and of presbyterians.  Recover a heart for Biblical worship by studying the resources on this page:

On the Simplicity & Spirituality of Worship

George Gillespie:

“That the [Anglican] Ceremonies are a great hinderance to edification appears, first, in that they obscure the substance of religion and weaken the life of godliness by outward glory and splendor, which draws away the minds of people so after it that they forget the substance of the service which they are about…  departing from the apostolical and most ancient simplicity, and for adding ceremonies unto ceremonies in a worldly splendor and spectability, whereas the worship of God ought to be pure and simple…

Secondly, the Ceremonies are impediments to the inward and spiritual worship, because they are fleshly and external…” – English Popish Ceremonies (1637), pp. 19-20

Church Ordinances & Order

The Reformation recognized that numerous commands in Scripture were for the good-order of the Church in their given context, and were not absolutely binding, without qualification, on all times and societies.

This Scriptural category of ‘Church ordinances’ was a common-place in Reformation theology, though it is virtually unrecognized in the conservative, reformed Church, especially among Biblicists.

With Churches adapting to the Corona outbreak, it is more necessary than ever to understand the ethical theology undergirding Church ordinances.  What is their binding nature?  May they be broken without guilt?

Read the Introduction and explore our Lord’s instruction with these reformed resources:

On the Ordinances, Order & Policy of the Church

Needless to say, it does not appear that any other significant collection on this topic exists on the net.  You will look in vain for a detailed discussion on this subject in modern systematic theologies, or any other theological book for that matter.

Tread in the old paths that were derived from the Word of God and have stood firm through many generations.

The History of Scottish Worship

It was said of the Scottish reformers: “The ministers that were took not their pattern from any Kirk [Church] in the world… but, laying God’s Word before them, made reformation according thereunto…” (John Row, 1637)

It is no exaggeration to say that the worship of God from the Scottish Reformation is the most important in Church history, it being the most closely aligned according to Scripture.

Here is a treasure of resources on the history of Scottish worship that will provide a plethora of information on every aspect of it, in every era.

The History of Scottish Worship

The Benediction

In Biblical worship, why does the minister close the worship service with an inspired Benediction, standing with up-lifted hands facing God’s people?

Here is a page of Biblical and historic, reformed resources on the Benediction, a Biblical practice not so easy to find resources on.

The Benediction

Some have said that the Benediction is not a prayer..  While acknowledging the special features of the Benediction, this article demonstrates from Scripture and Westminster that the Benediction is a special prayer:

Fentiman, Travis – The Benediction is a Special Prayer per Scripture and Westminster

How is Christ Worshipped as the Mediator?

We are to only worship God, and yet Jesus, a man, was worshipped in his earthly ministry.  How is this so?  The answer is that we worship Jesus, the God-man, not insofar as He is a creature, but insofar as his Person is God.

This precious jewel of theology is argued by the reformed theologians linked on the page below in a bit of detail that will be clear to the simplest, and make the most knowledgeable cry out:  “Oh! the depths and the riches!  (Rom. 11:33)

The Grounds of Christ the Mediator Receiving Divine Worship

Dance, Drama and Visual Imagery in Worship

Should dance, drama, plays, videos and man-made religious imagery be in worship?

As we are only to worship God in the way that He prescribes and as God has specifically regulated visual imagery in worship from the beginning, these things are an affront against the sole prerogative of the visual, dramatic signs that Christ has instituted in worship: Baptism and the Lord’s Supper.

Here is the most Biblically detailed argument available defending the historic, reformed practice against man-made religious imagery in God’s worship.  Please enjoy.

Visual Imagery, Drama & Dance in Worship

Psalters Online

Are you able to sing with David that “your statutes have been my songs in the house of my pilgrimage”? – Ps. 119:54

In order that you may find as rich treasure and grace in singing the Lord’s psalms as David did, we have collected as many psalters online as we could.  Previously we had around 60 through Church history.  Now the rather complete collection consists of over 115+, there being many new additions in the 1700’s-1900’s time-frame.

There are also new subsections on psalters for chanting, histories of composers and more:

Psalters Online

.

“Sing us one of the songs of Zion.”

Ps. 137:3

Family Worship

Do you love God and your family?

If you love God, you love more than anything in life communing with Him and worshipping Him, above the distractions of life.

If you love your family, you desire to provide them the best things.

And if you love both God and your family, you will find worshipping God with your family to be of the utmost desire. 

Learn more of what the Bible teaches about family worship, how to start doing it, be encouraged in continuing on with it, and find resources for help with it through the resources here:

Family Worship

Images of Christ

The Early Church and the Reformed wing of the Reformation held images of Christ to be unlawful in any context.  Why?  Because of the orthodox doctrine of the Hypostatic Union, of Christ’s one person in two natures.

Here is the crux of the issue:

In heaven, if you will be able to worship Jesus in the flesh, then you cannot make an image of Him.  If you can make an image of Him, then you cannot worship Him.

The ‘Introduction & Crux of the Issue’ on the webpage is irrefutable.  Many more resources on the topic, both historic and contemporary follow (which we have greatly updated).  Read, and wonder again that “God was in the flesh”.

Images of Christ

Dr. Hughes Oliphant Old, with the Lord

Dr. Hughes Oliphant Old, affectionately known as Scotti, one of the word’s leading historians of Christian, reformed worship, and a friend, went to be with our Savior at about 10:30 this morning, Tuesday, May 24, 2016.

Three weeks ago, I was able to see Scotti in his home. I asked him, ‘What song was it that Jesus was singing when he was going to the grave when it says in the gospels that after the Las Supper he sang a ‘hymn’?’

He replied, ‘Psalm 118‘. We were able to sing to him Ps. 118, the end of the great Hallel:

‘O set ye open unto me
the gates of righteousness;
Then will I enter into them,
and I the Lord will bless.

This is the gate of God, by it
the just shall enter in.
Thee will I praise, for thou me heard’st
and hast my safety been.’

Knowing that he loves the things of God’s Word, especially from the original languages, I told him, where we sing of ‘salvation’ in the psalter, the Hebrew word is ‘Yeshua’ ‘Jesus’. Jesus was singing his name in the prophesy of his death and resurrection. Ps. 118:14 ‘God my salvation [Jesus] is become, my Strength and Song is He.’ He exclaimed: ‘That’s amazing!’

Scotti in his last weeks, days, and hours was full of faith, trusting in God and our Savior. When I was with him this last Lord’s Day, the last words I heard breathed from his lips, barely articulate, though with all of his strength, was the doxology:

‘Praise God, from whom all blessings flow;
Praise him, all creatures here below;
Praise him above, ye heavenly host;
Praise Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Amen.’

 

Here is a tribute to Dr. Old, along with his last public address.

 

‘Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord from henceforth: Yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labours; and their works do follow them.’

Rev. 14:13

The Grounds of Christ the Mediator Receiving Worship

We are to only worship God, and yet Jesus, a man, was worshipped in his earthly ministry.  How is this so?  The answer is that we worship Jesus, the God-man, not insofar as He is a creature, but insofar as his Person is God.  Francis Cheynell, a Westminster divine, argues this precious jewel of theology in a bit of detail in a way that will be clear to the simplest, and make the most knowledgeable cry out: ‘Oh! the depths and the riches! (Rom. 11:33)  Learn also, in light of this, why the Second Commandment forbids all images of Jesus, God in the flesh.

The Grounds of Christ the Mediator Receiving Divine Worship  1650  20 pp.  with an Introduction and Outline

Articles on Worship

Being always at work building the Lord’s House (Hag. 1:2,4,8,9,14, etc.), we have been working on expanding, updating and overwhelmingly proving from Scripture and evidencing from history the Westminster viewpoint on Creeds and Responsive Readings in worship:

Creeds in Worship?

Responsive Readings

Offering in Worship

Take some time on the Lord’s Day to carefully consider the scriptures in light of these questions.  Particularly, there has been a subsection on the Book of Revelation added to the Responsive Readings page, which will be a great help searching and rightly dividing the Word of truth.  Many more articles on specific issues in worship, defending the Westminster perspective (which is not so popular these days) will be forthcoming in the months ahead.

Up next though, if the Lord so wills and we are spared, is All of the Writings of the Scottish Covenanters on one page.  Yes, that is right: ‘All’.  Check back in a week or two.