God’s Gracious Disposition, Inclination & Willingness

While God has effective decrees, bringing all to pass, and a will of revealed commands, it is sometimes denied with respect to the sincere, free offer of the gospel that God has a gracious disposition, inclination and willingness that his creatures, including those who are not elect, come to Him and be saved.

More basically, God has a disposition, inclination and willingness (1) for the good of his creatures, (2) to do them good and (3) is not willing that any should perish (Ex. 18:23; 2 Pet. 3:9).

Here is a large collection of articles and quotes from reformed theology’s classical era affirming these things.  Search into these depths and wonder at the mystery of our gracious God.

On a Divine Disposition, Inclination & Willingness

John Owen denied God has such a natural inclination.  Travis Fentiman has written a brief response to Owen on the same page solving his arguments and showing how it is possible God has a natural inclination for the good of his creatures, and to do them good, and that Scripture teaches this.

Twisse on God Willing the Salvation of All Men Indiscriminately

William Twisse, a moderator of the Westminster Assembly, has been known as a very ‘high’ Calvinist; so high, in fact, that many persons have used his very strong and continual language about God’s purposed destruction of reprobates against the notion that God wills their good or salvation in any way.  In fact, we long ago gave up trying to find in Twisse anything of the latter.

However, sure enough, we happened upon some places in Twisse where, in qualifying himself, he does, as Scripture, affirm God’s end of leading all men indiscriminately to repentance and salvation.

William Twisse on How God Wills the Salvation of Men Indiscriminately

There was a diversity of language and categories that the reformed used in the 1600’s on this subject, as is evident in Twisse here arguing against John Cotton, who used a stronger paradigm and language than Twisse.

The Marrow Controversy

The Marrow Controversy in early-1700’s Scotland hinged on the the warrant of the Free Offer of the Gospel displaying God’s grace and good-will to gospel-hearers.

Mature your understanding of the Christian faith in looking into this important and intriguing historical controversy.  Here are the most resources on the net about it.

As for us, we are Marrow men.  On this Lord’s Day, take up and read a sermon by one of the original Marrow Men, Thomas Boston, Ralph Erskine or Ebenezer Erskine, and delight your soul in these refreshing Gospel-waters,

The Marrow Controversy 

Adam Gib on the Free Offer

This is the best piece that Christian history has bequeathed to us on God’s Call in the Gospel Offer in relation to the Atonement.  Read it, and you will agree.  This may be the most important theological piece ReformedBooksOnline has published yet.  Gib (d. 1788) was a minister in the Scottish Secession Church.  Here he opens the door to God’s House of Mercy.

Concerning the Gospel Call and the Warrant of Faith  1747, 31 pages, from his The Present Truth: A Display of the Secession Testimony, vol. 2, Progression 5

 

 

James Durham on the Free Offer

Dr. Donald MacLean’s recent dissertation on James Durham and the Free Offer is now (largely) online and available for purchase.  Please enjoy! 

Maclean, Donald – James Durham (1622-1658) and the Gospel Offer in its Seventeenth Century Context  Buy  2015  311 pp.   

‘The free offer of the gospel has been a matter of significant debate within Reformed theology. However, despite this controversy, Reformed theologians such as James Durham preached a gospel offer which was a sincere and free invitation from God to all, to embrace Jesus Christ as Saviour. This gospel offer expressed God’s grace and goodness to all. Donald MacLean argues that Durham’s doctrinal position is representative of the Westminster Standards and embraced by his contemporaries and evidenced by the later disputes concerning the meaning of the teaching of the Westminster Confession of Faith.’

‘It is impossible to avoid the conclusion that Durham (1622-1658) teaches that God desires the salvation of all men.’

John Murray Compared with the Post-Reformation on the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel

Sometimes the claim is put forward that John Murray’s thesis on the Sincere, or Well-meant, offer of the Gospel in the mid-1900’s (that the Gospel Call to particular, unconverted sinners reflects God’s gracious nature and will for them to come to Him, and that God, by his Revealed Will, desires the salvation of all men) was novel and does not broadly represent historic, reformed theology from the days of the reformers and puritans in the 1500’s and 1600’s (the post-Reformation).  

So, to demonstrate that Murray’s position is broadly reflective of the majority, historic reformed viewpoint, we have summoned the testimony of one of the world’s leading authorities on the history of reformed theology during the post-Reformation era: Dr. Richard Muller.  

Below, for the sake of comparison, quotes from Murray have been provided followed by quotes from Muller summarizing the thought of the 1500’s and 1600’s, under 12 topical questions.  As will be seen, every element of Murray’s position on the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel was standard fare during the puritan era.  

John Murray Compared with the Post-Reformation on the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel

 

 

Richard Muller on Common Grace and the Sincere Free Offer

Muller is one of the leading reformed historians in the world today.  In his Dictionary of Latin and Greek Theological Terms and Post-Reformation Reformed Dogmatics, 4 vols., he summarizes the majority reformed views of the 1500’s and 1600’s.  It would be hard to quote a more authoritative name on the history of reformed theology than Richard Muller.  

Richard Muller on Common Grace and the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel

John Brown of Haddington on the Sincere Free Offer

It is often little known how common (universal almost) that the doctrine of the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel has been in reformed history.  So here is it is documented in another major reformed figure, of whom the world was not worthy.  Brown was an early 1700’s Scotsman who learned Greek on his own as a shepherd in the fields while he was young man, became a theological professor in the Secession Church, and is most well known today for his Systematic Theology (or, Natural and Revealed Religion, as it was originally published).

John Brown of Haddington on the Sincere Free Offer of the Gospel

Rutherford: The Gospel is Conditional

God holds eternal life out to us upon a condition (John 3:16).  If we believe in Christ, we will be saved.  If we do not believe in Christ, we will not receive what is offered, and we will perish.

While the gospel is not conditional as respects any merit or power in us (contrary to Arminianism), yet it is equally wrong to say with hyper-calvinists that the gospel has no conditions whatsoever.  Samuel Rutherford (a Westminster divine) here exposits (in congruity with the Westmisnter Larger Catechism #32) how the gospel has evangelical conditions, without which we will never see the Lord (Heb. 12:14). 

Rutherford, Samuel – The Gospel is Conditional  1648, 3 pages, being Part 2, Chapter 38, pp. 39-40 of his A Survey of the Spiritual Antichrist.

You must choose Christ to be saved

In this day and age of internet hyper-calvinism, sometimes the obvious must be stated:

You Must Choose Christ to be Saved

While man is passive in being born again, he, receiving a new nature that inclines to that which is spiritually good, is 100% active in turning from sin to Christ.  Thomas Manton, the puritan exhorts us to choose Christ, and William Cunningham the 1800’s Free Church of Scotland professor lays out the theology behind it.

Manton, Charnock, Gurnall, Burroughs, Greenhill and Boston on Striving with the Spirit

The puritans Thomas Manton, Stephen Charnock, William Gurnall, Jeremiah Burroughs, William Greenhill, and the later Thomas Boston have been excerpted on unbelievers (including the reprobate) striving against the Holy Spirit that would draw them to Christ.

These quotes demonstrate, along with the dozens of others, that God’s Revealed Will has purpose in it, namely to draw men at large to Christ, contra the hypercalvinist claims that God’s Revealed Will is static and purposeless and that God does not sincerely desire the salvation of those that He passes over in decree of Election and consequent irresistible grace.  The quotes have been added here:

The Common Operations of the Spirit

Do Enjoy.

The Three-Fold Love of God

Reformed Christianity has historically distinguished three aspects of the love of God.  He loves (1) all creation because it is his creation, (2) all people, because they are made in his image, and (3) the elect who He superlatively loves with a full complacency.  11 quotes by: Turretin, Leigh, Collinges, a Brakel, Jenkyn, Ussher, Gill, Hodge and Berkhof, Rutherford and Pictet.

The Three-Fold Love of God