The Light of Nature

The Westminster Confession speaks of “the light of nature” in several places (WCF 1.1; 1.6; 10.4; 20.4; 21.1).  It says that men may frame their lives according to the light of nature, that some things in the worship of God and Church government are to be ordered by it and that some opinions and practices are contrary to the light of nature.  The light of nature also shows that there is a God and manifests his wisdom, goodness and power.

What exactly is the light of nature, and what does it include?

As may be expected, Westminster was drawing upon a whole body of literature before them which answered these questions in some detail.  16 theses delineating the extent and limits of the light of nature, and its relationship to the light of grace, has been newly translated from the early-1600’s, German, reformed divine, Henry Alting.

These propositions will be a fountain of truth and wisdom to you, if you consider them well.

Alting, Henry – ‘A Disputation on the Light of Nature’  trans. T. Fentiman  (1628; RBO, 2022)  2 pp.  16 theses

How Church Rulings Do & Do Not Bind, & of Breaking Them

If the Church is not neglected today, it is often idolized; if Church authority is not disregarded, it is frequently turned absolute.

The Biblical and historically presbyterian position is that Church authority is conditional, and can only confirm the truth and what is good; it binds only insofar as God’s moral law binds antecedently within the situation itself.  To decline a positive order of Church government, apart from giving scandal and contempt of rightul authority, does not incur guilt.

Hence there is as much freedom in Christ’s House as God’s Law allows, and the Church’s government cannot with God’s authority turn into a capricious bear-trap.

Learn the ins and outs of when it is right to obey the Church, and when it is wrong; your welfare may depend on it.  You won’t find this essential subject for the Christian life treated in such solid detail anywhere else.

How Church Rulings Do & Do Not Bind, on Guilt & Innocence in Breaking Them, & on Contumacy

On Jurisprudence

Rulers are to rule in equity (Ps. 99:4; Prov. 17:26).  While even the humblest believer can recognize the rightness or wrongness of a case laid before him (1 Cor. 6), yet we are to exercise our senses in order to be able to discern good and evil in greater maturity (Heb. 5:14), especially as we are called to as mothers and fathers, elders and those who hold offices in business or the civil government.

History has bequeathed to us an extensive and profound collection of writings elaborating on what constitutes equity according to Natural Law.  This is a field in which believers can learn a lot in from natural men.

Many books of Church order are surprisingly sparse with respect to guidance in many particulars.  Rather than making things up as one goes, expand your awareness of the principles of equity and justice:

On Jurisprudence

Specifically, we have been happily surprised with how much profit, spiritual as well as natural, we have found in collections of Legal Maxims.

.

“He loveth righteousness and judgment…”

Ps. 33:5

How Far Human Laws Bind the Conscience

One of the most constantly relevant and important ethical questions in the Christian life is how far human laws and commands bind us.  We are constantly presented with commands in school, work, in the family, in the Church and in our State which are less than obviously, morally necessary.

The best strand of historic, reformed theology, including Perkins and Rutherford, has answered that only God’s natural, moral and positive laws can bind creatures.  Human, positive commands bind only insofar as they reflect God’s laws.

While we are to honor God-given human authorities (by God’s moral law, the 5th Commandment) and are to seek to prevent scandal (by God’s moral law, the 6th Commandment), yet human authorities can add no morally binding obligation whatsoever to a matter; rather, they are to use their God given office, station, power and resources to enforce God’s moral law, and in so doing, they exercise true authority from God’s Will.

Hence human laws and commands bind only insofar as they reflect God’s laws in the situation, and to that degree only.  As all authorities have only been given authority from God for good, truth and edification, any action other than that is outside the powers of their office (ultra vires) and does not inherently bind.

All this is to say that all persons and authorities are to obey God’s natural, moral and positive laws, even when authorities do not rule accurately according thereto, as God is to be obeyed before men and as He is the Lord of the conscience alone.

Learn from the best of reformed theology and walk more closely in the Lord’s paths:

How Far the Laws & Commands of Human Authorities Bind the Conscience

On Arbitrary Laws & Implicit Faith & Obedience

God’s Law is the only thing that can morally bind his creatures, as there is fundamentally only one Lawgiver (Isa. 33:22; James 4:12).

Hence, all human laws and commands, including from those who hold public offices of God, only oblige as far those commands reflect God’s Law inherent in the situation itself, and to that degree.

Yet persons and authorities often expect to be obeyed simply because they have so willed it.  When you are presented with this unpleasant situation, here is a page of reformed resources that will help you understand this error (and the truth it opposes) better, and it will confirm you in walking in this life as a servant of God, and not of men.

On Arbitrary Laws & Commands

Likewise, to give anyone besides God our implicit faith and obedience (if they demand of us to believe or obey anything wherein a sufficient moral reason is not perceived or given to our conscience) is against the 2nd and 7th Commandments:

It is written: “What doth the Lord thy God require of thee, but to…  love Him and to serve the Lord thy God…” (Dt. 10:12)  But to serve the will of man apart from being able to serve God’s will in the matter is idolatry, to enthrone service to the creature above God.  It is also to perversely give up our soul’s most precious inner-chamber, reserved for God alone, to be used by men.

On Implicit, or Blind Faith & Obedience

On Positive Laws

One of the most important ethical distinctions, extensively relevant to the Christian life and on which there is very little teaching in the Church today, is the difference between (1) Natural Law & (2) Positive Laws.

(1) Natural Law includes the inherent designs that God created into Creation, natural human inclinations and fundamental natural principles of obliging force.

(2) Positive Laws are all specific commands and laws of humans in society, which ought to be based on natural laws, though they inherently contain some amount of arbitrariness to them.

In necessity, Natural laws override Positive Laws.

A great familiarity with this distinction and its extensive relevance all around us is most needed during our societal response to COVID (some of which response is good and some of which is not adequately based on Natural Law), during riots and even in the very mundane issues of work and family life.

It also very much applies to the government of the Church and defending oneself under unjust Church discipline.

Further, the issue is theological:  God makes ethically binding positive laws, and He abrogates them.  Delve into the rich things of the Lord’s revelation and greatly expand your understanding.

Lastly, how far do positive laws bind the conscience?  In contrast to the fuzziness and lack of clarity on this point in the modern Church, there was a large puritan consensus on the matter which is both clear, precise and dead-on right.

Read the Introduction on the page and grow in your walking before the Lord and men:

On Positive Laws & Ordinances, & the Law of Nations

Constitutionalism

A Church’s constitution, subordinate to the Word of God, defines its being and public testimony.

Officers’ vows define the officers’ relationship to the Church and obligates them to uphold the Church’s constitution, as opposed to undermining it.  The constitution serves as a legal security to minorities who seek to uphold the acknowledged principles of the Church.  A change in the constitution, apart from the lawful process thereto, effectively breaks the terms of union by which persons are bound to the Church.

Learn more about the principles of Constitutionalism here, with the most mature, balanced and developed resources on the topic from Church history.

Here is much needed health for the Church today.

Constitutionalism

Antinomiansim = ‘Against the Law’

Antinomiansim is rife in the Christian world today.  Jesus says, ‘If you love me, keep my commandments.’ (Jn. 14:15)  And yet how often do Christians say that trying to keep God’s commandments is legalism?

We seek to keep God’s commandments not to earn our salvation, but in being saved by grace through faith, apart from our works, we seek to obey God by his Spirit in order to glorify Him.  As long as we are creatures, God’s Moral Law by Creation morally binds us.  Faith does not make the Law void, but rather establishes it. (Rom. 3:31)

John ‘Rabbi’ Duncan called Antinomianims the only heresy.  Find out why, and many more things on this page we put together on the topic:

Antinomianism

You will learn much from this webpage; it is worth your time.

 

 

The General Equity of the Judicial Law

Wherever there is a vacuum of sound, Biblical teaching, errors breed and multiply as sincere Christians try to reinvent a doctrinal wheel from Scripture.  

There has for a long time been a nearly complete silence in American Christianity (Reformed included) on what the general equity of the Old Testament Judicial Law entails.  In its place has crept in the polar alternatives of status-quo, civilly protected polytheism (of the Book of Judges and American tradition) and Mosaic Theonomy.  

Fortunately, that vacuum has officially now ended.  Learn why the Biblical and majority view of the Reformation and Puritan eras on General Equity is right:

The General Equity of the Old Testament Civil Laws

As the faithful Church is the pillar and ground of the truth (1 Tim. 3:15), it is never safe to take a minority view of something in Scripture until you, at least, know all of the reasons for the majority view.  May we seek to reform according to the Word of God as we learn from godlier and more knowledgeable saints of old than we.

Rutherford on the Judicial Laws

How do the Judicial Laws of Moses apply today to our civil politics?  There are two extremes:

– Christian evangelicalism which accepts pluralism and finds no use for the divinely given pattern revealed in Moses, and

– Theonomy which says that the Judicial Laws of Moses are as binding, in exhaustive detail, as they ever were.

There is another choice, though: the historic, majority Reformed view that the Judicial Law as a category has expired, except as its General Equity (Moral Principles) continue to bind today.

Samuel Rutherford expounds and illustrates the viewpoint of the Westminster Confession.  Let Rutherford take you to school and teach you what General Equity Biblically, and has historically, entailed:

Samuel Rutherford on the Judicial Laws of Moses: Excerpts Arranged Topically  32 pp.

Expositions of the Ten Commandments

While we do not keep God’s Law in order to earn our salvation (which is through faith alone by the grace and righteousness of our Savior alone, Gal. 2:16), those who are born again through the Gospel and enlivened by the Holy Spirit seek to love, please and glorify God by doing what He says (Jn. 14:15; Lk. 3:10-14; Rom. 7:22; 1 Jn. 5:3) by faith and dependence upon Christ (Jn. 15:5; Phil. 4:13).  In doing so, we find that God’s Law is a light to our path (Ps. 119:105), for our good (Ps. 34:11-14;Prov. 3) and that the end thereof is blessing (Ex. 20:6,12; Jn. 15:10; Jm. 1:25; Rev. 14:13).

To this end, be like the Psalmist and meditate on God’s Law day and night (Ps. 1:1-3), and you will find that ‘The law of Thy mouth is better unto me than thousands of gold and silver.’ (Ps. 119:72)

Expositions of the Ten Commandments

 

Puritan Francis Roberts on the Moral Law, Judicial Law and Natural Law

Francis Roberts was an influential English puritan who wrote the 1,700 page puritan magnum opus on Covenant Theology.  Here are two sections from it.

The first deals with the differences between the Moral Law and the Judicial Law and upholds the viewpoint of the Westminster Confession, contra Theonomy.

On the Moral Law and the Judicial Law

The second deals with the similarities and differences between the Moral Law and Natural Law.  In the midst of current discussions on the subject, here is some sanity:

On the Moral Law and the Law of Nature