Duns Scotus in English & on his Thought

When Reformed theologians did theological retrieval, they often drew from the detailed paradigms that had already been laid down by two opposite poles of philosophical theology in the Middle Ages: Aquinas and Duns Scotus.

It has been hard to get a hold of the writings of Scotus in English, till now.  Scotus’s main systematic work, the Ordinatio, has in the last few years been professionally translated and is free on the net.

The level of detail in the scholastic tradition has not been surpassed, making help in understanding their positions welcome.  This new page has not only collected Scotus’s writings in English, but also surveys of his thought.  Another page has been devoted to Scotus’s influence through history (including amongst the Reformed).

‘Duns Scotus in English & on his Thought’

‘On the Reception of Scotus in Church History’

A Scotist Proof for God

Allan B. Wolter (†2006) was an American, Franciscan, John Duns Scotus (d. 1308) scholar and professor of philosophy.  He provided a medium-level proof for God in the scholastic tradition from the existence (or possibility) of transient being, or change, which starting premise is undeniable.

The proof follows his (also arguably undeniable) 69 conclusions respecting reality, which metaphysical conclusions are very valuable in their own right.  Upon them, the existence of only one infinitely perfect, omniscient and omnipotent, uncaused personal being necessarily follows, whom we call God.

Fentiman has written an introduction to the proof which will be helpful in understanding it; he also in short space gives reasons and defends that the nature of things is objective and that God can be proven in a linear fashion therefrom.

Metaphysics is the study of being, which may be profitable to all of us.  Up your level in taking a look and assure your faith in God’s eternal, necessary existence as ultimate reality, He being more sure than the reality surrounding us, or our own existence.

‘Allan Wolter’s Conclusions respecting Reality, Proving God’

.

“I Am that I Am.”

Ex. 3:14

All the Councils in Greek & Latin

Where can you find all the councils of Church history in their original languages?  On this new page:

The Councils of Church History in Greek & Latin

To find not just some excerpts of the councils, but all their creeds, canons, acts and documents can be quite challenging, until now.

For ease of use, a section of resources putting an English translation next to the Greek and Latin is provided for the most important passages from the most important of these councils.

But if you want all 53 volumes plus of the councils in Latin (every Greek passage has a Latin translation) up through 1902, in a digestible format, you have found the mother lode.

Commentaries on Lombard’s Sentences

The Medieval Peter Lombard (†1160) was the fountainhead of systematic theology in the Church’s Western tradition.  His Four Books of Sentences, or theological judgments, has likely been the most influential book of theology ever.

Through the 1500’s throughout Europe, to gain a doctorate one had to give a commentary on the Master’s Sentences.  Hence, every Medieval theologian of prominence wrote a commentary.  Over 1,700 such commentaries have survived through history.  Yet the Sentences were only translated into English in 2007, and are not easy to access in Latin online, till now.

Lombard’s work is devoutly pious, is a gateway to the earlier fathers, and, despite it containing some of the errors of his age, is historically aware and full of legitimate (and edifying), detailed theology, much more so in fact than many contemporary systematic theologies.

Our new webpage has translated the Sentences‘ detailed table of contents, with links provided, so you can see what is in the work.  We have also collected over 80 Sentence commentaries (almost all are in Latin), forming a corpus of the most prominent Medieval theologians and some of the most detailed theology across the theological gamut ever written in Church history.  The Reformed often resourced the Medievals, for good reasons.

For the commentaries of John Duns Scotus, Gregory of Rimini (a favorite of the Reformed), Martin Luther (yes, the Protestant reformer) and the reformed theologian Lambert Daneau, we have translated their detailed tables of contents and provided links.

Lombard’s Sentences, Commentaries on Them, etc.

Resources are also linked on the Lombard’s life, his theology and Sentences and their commentaries.  May this collection be helpful to you and others in further looking into and understanding our Lord’s things and the deveolopment of Christ’s Church.

The Church Fathers in Greek & Latin

Patrologia Graeca and Patrologia Latina are the standard, older, massive series of volumes of the writings of the early and medieval Church fathers, all online.  We have put them all on one webpage.  This webpage is the easiest and most convenient way to access and use them on the net.

As almost all the Greek writings have a Latin translation on the facing column, if you are able to learn and read Latin, you can read almost all the fathers throughout Church history.  The Reformed Orthodox regularly reference the fathers; here is where you can find them.

Many helpful links are provided, such as to where the series have been digitized and are fully searchable.  The indices on the page allow one to find for a topic of interest (whether theological, Scriptural, historical, etc.) all the places in the early and medieval Church where it is addressed, making this an invaluable resource.

The Fathers in Greek & Latin: Patrologia Graeca & Latina

If this page be a blessing to you, bless God through it.  “For of Him, and through Him, and to Him, are all things: to whom be glory forever.” (Rom. 11:36)

Where Reformed Orthodox Writers Agreed & Disagreed with Aquinas

Where did the Reformed in her classical era agree and disagree with Aquinas?

In light of the resurgence of Protestant interest in Aquinas, this new webpage with an Intro is a large reference list, going through the whole gamut of theology, juxtaposing Aquinas with Reformed Orthodox theologians on each theological point, listing and documenting their agreements and then disagreements.

Contrary to a popular belief, the Reformed did disagree with Aquinas on aspects of his doctrine of God, the Trinity, Christ, Predestination and Natural Law, as well as about everything else.

Some Protestants reading Aquinas have begun to imbibe some of his Romanist doctrines.  Others, wholly write him off as a bad influence, and miss out on the tremendous profit that can be gleaned from him.

While we do not recommend that new Christians, or the uninformed, read Aquinas, yet Reformed theologians in the Post-Reformation critically appropriated Aquinas, benefiting from him where they could. This webpage lays it out in front of you, taking out the mystery.  If you have interest in beginning to read Aquinas, this is a great place to start.

You will learn A LOT of some of the most precious and detailed theology about our Lord, his Christ, and our salvation, nearly nowhere else to be easily found, just by reading through this page:

‘Where Reformed Orthodox Writers Agreed & Disagreed with Aquinas’

We have also collected resources ‘On the Reception of Aquinas in Church History’.

.

“For inquire, I pray you, of the former age, and prepare yourself to the search of their fathers
(for we are but of yesterday and know nothing, because our days upon earth are a shadow).

Shall not they teach you and tell you, and utter words out of their heart?”

Job 8:8-11

Early & Medieval Church Bible Commentaries Online

We live in extraordinary times.  In the benevolent provision of God we have been able to compile a collection of more than 575 bible commentaries in English from early and medieval Church figures, around 64% of which are fully available online for free:

The Early & Medieval Church Fathers on Scripture

When RBO was started about 9 years ago, around a fifth of this was available.

The webpage is nearly endless in how far it allows you to search into the fathers on Scripture.  The page includes the latest and most comprenseive online indices of quotes on Scripture by the fathers, as well as nearly exhaustive, standard, scholarly works: (1) referring to further commentaries in Latin, and (2) providing the fathers’ citations of Scripture, at a few clicks of the button.

Persons and scholars with interest in Scriptural commentary, or the early and Medieval Christians, and everyone in between, will be elated.  Make your interested friends happy.

.

“I am the Lord thy God…  open thy mouth wide, and I will fill it.”

Ps. 81:10

Medieval Church History

Here is a wealth of resources on Medieval Church history which will answer just about any question you have about it.  We have harvested the public domain on the topic for you and have found many of the standard sources on the subject, in addition to contemporary scholarship as well.

In particular, in the midst of the liberal, popular opinion that Islam is a peaceful religion, get the truth here. We highly recommend the works of Bat Ye’or, who has thoroughly and impartially shown at length and in detail what it was like to be a ‘dhimmi’ (non-muslim) under Islam historically and through the modern era, with first-rate scholarship.

Medieval Church History & Renaissance

Early Church History

We have collected the harvest of histories on the early Church from the public domain.

The early Church will always be dear to the one to whom the Lord Jesus is dear to, as these early Christians came right off the heels of Christ’s commissioned apostles themselves.  As always though, as some of the most-in-depth sources have been written by liberals and secularists, discernment is needed to separate the wheat from the chaff.

For those who are a bit further along and know some Greek and Latin, but have not yet attempted to jump into the 161 volumes of Greek patristic writings and 221 volumes of Latin patristic writings (which is not easy to do), but desire to make some progress herein, we have some easy directions and tools in our Primary Sources section that will allow you to do just this.  It is the only place on the net that we know of which provides such a key to opening these treasures.

We hope that you find this of great value:

Early Church History

Church History

We have collected the cream of the crop of Church histories that span the whole of the Christian era for you off of the internet.

Have a question about something in Church history?  You will find a larger wealth of information on the topic here than you ever desired.

The beginner will find a number of great recommendations to start with.  The advanced material is amazing, though one must read with discernment.  Please enjoy the best of Church history in the public domain!

Church History

[The subsections on specific periods in Church history, such as the early church, medieval church, etc. are still under construction]

Historical Theology

Historical theology is Scriptural theology organized and viewed through the way it has been recognized and developed through the history of the Church.

Why is historical theology dearly precious?  Because nearly every aspect of Scriptural teaching has been hammered out in more profound earnestness and depth by the godly giants of the past, and their personal stories, than we can comprehend.

Here is a collection of the major historical theologies on the net:

Historical Theology

May you find it a blessing.

We now have rather full collections at ReformedBooksOnline of the three main divisions of theology: Historical, Biblical and Systematic.