Man as Active in Conversion & on being Born Again as after Faith

In the Lord making us born again by his Spirit (Jn. 3:3-8), are we passive or active therein?  Classic reformed theology has answered: “Both”.  We are passive in the first instant, but after that active, in repenting of our sins and trusting the Lord Jesus for eternal salvation.

Likewise, while being “born again” can refer to the Lord’s enlivening us so as to believe, it often in Scripture, and classic reformed theology, is spoken of as after faith, when we enter a fuller newness of life in spritual communion with Christ by means of receiving Him into our hearts through faith, He beginning to live in us, with all the blessings He brings (Rev. 3:20).

We ought to affirm and value all the truths we can about these things and not deny that man is in significant ways active and cooperative in regeneration, and that there is a newness of life in being born again by faith.  We are not blocks and stones.  Affirming these truths will help us walk closer with fellow Christians who see some of these things, though not all of them.

Grow in the Lord with these new pages of classic reformed resources:

‘Only the Initial Aspect of Regeneration is by the Lord Working Alone, Man being Wholly Passive therein’

‘On being Born Again as Subsequent to Faith, in receiving Christ & the Fullness of Life by Faith’

Presumptive Regeneration

What is to be made of Presumptive Regeneration, which has become so popular in the modern, Reformed Church?

Jesus told Nicodemus, who was a teacher in Israel and externally in the Covenant in good standing, “You must be born again.” (Jn. 3:7)

It is largely not known that the classical era of Presbyterianism in the 1600’s largely argued against Presumptive Regeneration in their controversy with the Separatists, Independents and Congregationalists, who all advocated it.

Here is a dozen of the most detailed and extensive writings against Presumptive Regeneration in Church history (all from presbyterians: Rutherford, Dickson, Fergusson, Rathband, Apollonius, etc.), with an extensive and Scripturally detailed Introduction to the topic:

Presumptive Regeneration

There is a special section in the Introduction, at the end, on ‘Raising Children in the Covenant’.

Experiential Religion

What is Experiential Religion?

Jonathan Edwards:

“A gracious experience arises from operations and influences which are spiritual, from an inward principle which is divine, a communication of God, a participation of the divine nature [2 Pet. 1:4]: Christ living in the heart, the Holy Spirit dwelling there in union with the faculties of the soul as an internal principle, exerting his own proper nature in the exercise of those faculties.”

Thus all of that which we go through in life in its various seasons, circumstances and experiences as we live before the Face of God, becomes sanctified and beneficial to our faith and precious to the saint.

Experiential Religion deeply values the experiential aspect of the Scriptures and the Christian faith.

Here is a field of jewels from Church history on experiential religion, on one page:

Experiential Religion

Puritan Richard Rogers on Conversion

Two newly edited sermons by the puritan Richard Rogers (1612) on Conversion have been published!

These very experientially rich sermons on conversion lay the entrance to God’s kingdom sweetly low: to any that thirst for it.  Rogers, with a discerning and soft hand, reproves worldly minded persons who do not desire the best things (even their own salvation), shows that the way to be saved is to thirst for it (for those that desire what God offers), and assures those that do thirst that God will surely make good his end of the deal.  It is in thirsting that the Christian continues in this life to receive the best spiritual graces from God for everything that he or she needs. 

Two Sermons on Conversion from Deut. 5-28-29  1612, 21 pages

Deut. 5:29:

‘Oh! That there were such a heart in them to fear me, and to keep all my commandments always; that it might go well with them, and with their children forever!’

Richard Rogers’ Two Sermons on Conversion from Isa. 55

Richard Rogers’ (1551-1618) famed reply to the scoffer, ‘I serve a precise God’, gave the occasion for the puritans to be called ‘precisionists’.  These two very experientially rich sermons on conversion lay the entrance to God’s kingdom sweetly low: to any that thirst for it.  Rogers, with a discerning and soft hand, reproves worldly minded persons who do not desire the best things (even their own salvation), shows that the way to be saved is to thirst for it (for those that desire what God offers), and assures those that do thirst that God will surely make good his end of the deal.  It is in thirsting that the Christian continues in this life to receive the best spiritual graces from God for everything that he or she needs. 

Two Sermons on Conversion from Isa. 55:1-2, 1612, 29 pages, including a Publisher’s Introduction and a Preface by Rogers

You must choose Christ to be saved

In this day and age of internet hyper-calvinism, sometimes the obvious must be stated:

You Must Choose Christ to be Saved

While man is passive in being born again, he, receiving a new nature that inclines to that which is spiritually good, is 100% active in turning from sin to Christ.  Thomas Manton, the puritan exhorts us to choose Christ, and William Cunningham the 1800’s Free Church of Scotland professor lays out the theology behind it.

Asahel Nettleton

Nettleton (1783-1844) was a Calvinist pastor from Connecticut who was influential in America’s Second Great Awakening.  His writings are very rich, fervent and are highly recommended.  Quotes from him on striving with the Spirit, the Fatherhood of God, and Natural vs. Moral Inability have been added to their respective pages.  Enjoy:

Historic Reformed Quotes on the Fatherhood of God

Gardiner Spring (d. 1873), also a Calvinist pastor from New England involved in the Second Great Awakening, has been added on Fatherhood as well.

The Common Operations of the Spirit

Nettleton on Natural vs. Moral Inability

 

Manton, Charnock, Gurnall, Burroughs, Greenhill and Boston on Striving with the Spirit

The puritans Thomas Manton, Stephen Charnock, William Gurnall, Jeremiah Burroughs, William Greenhill, and the later Thomas Boston have been excerpted on unbelievers (including the reprobate) striving against the Holy Spirit that would draw them to Christ.

These quotes demonstrate, along with the dozens of others, that God’s Revealed Will has purpose in it, namely to draw men at large to Christ, contra the hypercalvinist claims that God’s Revealed Will is static and purposeless and that God does not sincerely desire the salvation of those that He passes over in decree of Election and consequent irresistible grace.  The quotes have been added here:

The Common Operations of the Spirit

Do Enjoy.