What is to be made of Presumptive Regeneration, which has become so popular in the modern, Reformed Church?
Jesus told Nicodemus, who was a teacher in Israel and externally in the Covenant in good standing, “You must be born again.” (Jn. 3:7)
It is largely not known that the classical era of Presbyterianism in the 1600’s largely argued against Presumptive Regeneration in their controversy with the Separatists, Independents and Congregationalists, who all advocated it.
Here is a dozen of the most detailed and extensive writings against Presumptive Regeneration in Church history (all from presbyterians: Rutherford, Dickson, Fergusson, Rathband, Apollonius, etc.), with an extensive and Scripturally detailed Introduction to the topic:
There is a special section in the Introduction, at the end, on ‘Raising Children in the Covenant’.