Defense of Moderate Puritanism & Principled Partial Conformity

The moderate puritans are often looked upon as compromisers in partially conforming to things not wholly right in the Church (and State); yet their reasons for this are little known.

This newly edited book from the archives is a one of a kind jewel.  Written by a group of unnamed English reformed ministers (in the trajectory of divine-right presbyterianism), they defend their outlook from the Scriptures while arguing against both the Conformists and Separatists, while preserving the Church as one (Jn. 17:20–23) in the fundamentals of the Faith, without sacrificing principles.

The Extended Introduction by Travis Fentiman (MDiv) sets forth the Scriptural case for principled partial conformity in worship and Church government, against George Gillespie.  It also documents that most of the Westminster divines were conformists to some degree under pain of ministerial deprivation, and shows how partial conformity is consistent with the Westminster standards.  The surprising breadth of Westminster’s parameters on worship is historically brought to light in consideration of its original intent.

The fascinating untold story of the indulged covenanting ministers in Scotland during 1669-1688, those who partially conformed to the undue impositions of the civil government, is narrated and defended from Scripture, especially against the arguments of that ultra non-conformist, John Brown of Wamphray.  The civil dethroning principles of the 1680’s Scottish Cameronians are shown to be erroneous and contrary to the reformed, puritan and covenanting tradition as especially summed up in Samuel Rutherford’s Lex Rex (1644).

An honest and not simplistic view of the Solemn League and Covenant (1643) is surveyed, drawing on some of the latest historical research, supporting the partial conforming trajectory.

Lastly, the Extended Intro drives against denominationalism and the wrong-headedness of erecting denominational white towers, seeking the unifying of Christ’s Church through the catholic principles of Scripture, Westminster, the Scots and the London presbyterians.  Church union in (at least) Christianity’s fundamentals will be seen to oblige from God’s Word, as many of the reformed, the London presbyterians and the Scottish covenanter James Durham taught.  Separation for secondary matters that do not tend to overturn the fundamentals is seen to be schism (notwithstanding your denomination’s constitution, vows, covenants, etc.).

See the first several pages of the Extended Intro for what other things are treated of and argued in the book.  Theological treasures are yours for the reaping; take up and read!

English Puritans – A Refutation of the Errors of Separatists  (1604; 1644; RBO, 2025)  300 pp.  with an Extended Intro by Travis Fentiman: “Defending the Lawfulness of Partial-Conformity in Worship & Church Government (including under Civil Impositions) from Scripture, Westminster & the Scottish Indulgence Controversy, contra George Gillespie, while Driving against Denominationalism, for the Unifying of Christ’s Church”

Baxter against Separatism & John Owen

Separatism is often heralded as the height of Christian virtue, that one must separate from nearly every church or worship error.  Many Christians who would not go that far, may yet have latent separatistic tendencies.  Richard Baxter, in this newly cleaned up piece, demolishes the principles of Separatism.

His opponent?  John Owen.  Owen had written a tract arguing for separation, at least for those who had “engaged unto reformation,” from ever attending the Anglican liturgy.  In it Owen uses principles that may sound like the height of righteousness, but are separatist.  Baxter (rightly) convicts him of 42 errors.

The article has an editor’s Introduction.  If you have interest in worship issues, you will learn a lot.  May it humble us and cause us to more greatly love the Lord, his worship and his people.

Baxter, Richard – Richard Baxter on Worship & Catholicity against Separatism & John Owen  (RBO, 2024)  87 pp.

Need Permission to Leave a Church?

With the rise of an emphasis on the local church, membership and the authority of elders, some have concluded that a church member needs permission from the elders to leave a church.  This was the teaching of congregationalism in contrast to presbyterianism during the puritan era.

This new page of resources with an Introduction argues from Scripture and nature the classic presbyterian position, that, while one ought always to serve the laws of charity, edification and good order, yet one may absent themselves from Church functions and the church itself due to moral and providential necessities, according to the Law of God, without permission from elders or necessarily giving them one’s reasons, and that letters of transfer (or other certificates), while useful, are not ultimately necessary.

As all things are to be done unto edification (1 Cor. 14:26), numerous puritans taught a person may leave one church for a more profitable church.  So far from the Church being instituted by the Lord as a destructive trap (2 Cor. 10:8; 13:10), Christ’s house is a free society for all those that walk uprightly serving their Lord.

One May Miss Services & Leave a Church due to Providence without Permission, & a Letter of Transfer is Not Necessary

Seeking the Peace & Purity of the Church

One of the main aims of Church discipline, which should also be the aim of all Christians, is to seek the peace and purity of Christ’s Church.

It is not always readily clear however, what that principle calls for in particular situations; and the phrase is often readily misused by those who have little care for the purity of the Church, or her peace.  If all parties are seeking the peace of the Church in purity, and seeking the purity of the Church in peace, disputes and scandals can be resolved in a healthy manner.

Here are numerous historic resources that will help you and your Church in seeking the peace and purity of Christ’s Kingdom:

On the Peace & Purity of the Church

What Constitutes the Fundamentals of Christianity & How Bad are Errors Beyond Them?

What precisely must one believe to be saved?  Given the variety of people’s background, understanding and what is told them of Christianity, even as exampled in Scripture, that is not an easy question to answer.

If people profess serious errors that seem to overturn the fundamentals of Christianity, though they yet profess to believe in those fundamental teachings of the True Faith, will they be saved?  Are they professing Christians?  May we have fellowship with such a Church?

The topic of the fundamental and secondary teachings of Christianity is at once a profoundly basic issue, and yet it is incredibly complex with many real world implications.  Should a baptist be allowed to be a member of a church reformed according to the Word of God?  Should an Arminian?

Little is it known that there was a large, reformed consensus in these issues amongst the presbyterians in the puritan era, even in the minute details, and that not simply from human agreement, but as it was proved by the Word of God and the light of nature.

You will learn a lot.  See especially Witsius.  And, as usual, git wrekt by Rutherford:

Of Fundamental, Secondary & Tertiary Matters of Christianity, of Errors Therein & of Communion, Discipline & Separation Thereabout

Against Separation from Impure Civil Governments

If our civil government is not Christian, has many impurities and corruptions in it, and is driven by ungodly rulers, are we able to wholesale write-off its authority, or are we to obey it as unto the Lord in their lawful injunctions?

Inform yourself of the majority, historic reformed, and Westminster viewpoint, and may it cause us to walk with greater circumspection in the fear and holiness of God.

Against Separation from Impure Civil Governments