Discussions on Church Principles: Popish, Erastian and Presbyterian, Buy 1863, 565 pages, with a four page preface by James Buchanan and James Bannerman
Many people are aware of Bannerman’s Church of Christ, which positively expounds the doctrine of the Church from scripture. Cunningham’s work is more polemical, against the errors of alternative views. Both are needed. This is his main work on Church writings, a subject too often neglected in our day.
Delivered during the ten year Non-Intrusion controversy (of the State intruding into the affairs of the Church) that led up the the Disruption in 1843.
A classic, the first historical theology you should go to. Many history books are simply a rehashing of a well-worn narrative, Cunningham instead thought that the most valuable part of Christian history was in the lessons learned as truth, error and God’s revelation are sifted through the ages.
Here Cunningham is at his best, church history and the principles of the Reformation being his life’s work.
Evangelicals in the Church of Scotland were able to pass the Veto Act in the Church in 1834, which upheld the Biblical principle that ministers could not be forced onto a congregation by the civil government. The Veto Act was overturned in the civil courts in 1838, leading to a battle between Church and State which culminated in the Disruption of 1843. Robertson was a moderate minister in the Church of Scotland whose Observations upon the Veto Act, 1839, criticized it and sought for its removal in the Church. Cunningham here defends the Veto Act, contrary to the civil government. May such courage be given to us today when the church often blindly follows the will of Caesar instead of the will of God.
This collection of lectures in its subject matter forms an extended exposition of the first chapter of the Westminster Confession. Cunningham “had bestowed much care and labor upon their composition and revision, and that he had attached a special value to them as the first-fruits of his professional labors.”
Book of Sermons
Chapters From His Own Books (12)
The Arminian Controversy, from his Historical Theology, vol 2 ch. 25, p. 383-525
The Church of the First Two Centuries: the Doctrines of Grace, from his Historical Theology, Ch. 7, 6 paragraphs
The Heresies of the Apostolic Age, from his Historical Theology, vol. 1, ch. 5, p. 121-133, of the Banner of Truth edition
The Reformers: Lessons from their History, HTML, from his The Reformers and the Theology of the Reformation, Banner of Truth, 1967 edition, pp 600-608.
The Sacramental Principle, HTML, from his Historical Theology
The Socinian Controversy, from his Historical Theology, vol 2, ch. 23, p. 155-236
The Westminster Confession on the Relation Between Church and State, HTML, 1843, from a pamphlet published in May 1843, immediately before the Disruption of the Church of Scotland, entitled, “Remarks on the Twenty-third Chapter of the Confession of Faith as bearing on existing Controversies”, published later in his Discussions on Church Principles, ch. 8
Many people today charge the original Westminster Confession of 1646 with Erastianism (that the State is over the Church). This is a charge made out of ignorance. The Confession teaches against Erastianism, but does teach the Biblical and historic reformed doctrine of the Establishment Principle. American Presbyterianism, though it denies the Establishment Principle, yet owes its life to it, as the Westminster Assembly was originally called to sit by the Parliament (civil magistrate) of England. Cunningham vindicates the original Confession.
Chapters from Others’ Books
The Nature and Lawfulness of Union Between Church and State, HTML, 1835, 70 pages, from Lectures on the Nature and Lawfulness, Duty and Advantages of Civil Establishments of Religion, a collection of essays by various authors
Isaiah 49:23 says of the Church, “and kings shall be thy nursing fathers, and their queens thy nursing mothers.” In what sense is this truth of scripture to be understood? Find out here.
Calvin and Servetus, 1825, with a four page introduction by editor James Gracie
The best article on the issue of the Genevan civil courts putting the anti-trinitarian blasphemer and fugitive Michael Servetus to death
The Opposition of the Westminster Assembly to Popery, Prelacy and Erastianism, 1843, 11 pages, starting on p. 52 of Commemoration of the Bicentenary of the Westminster Assembly of Divines: held at Edinburgh, 1843, Containing the Addresses and Conversations, Buy 158 pages
Speech on Covenanting at the 1847 General Assembly of the Free Church of Scotland, 1847, the easiest way to read this is: open the link, right-click on the page, save-as to your computer. Open the PDF from your computer. Rotate once clockwise (found under the menu label “View”), then magnify the document several times until it is large enough to read easily. Robert Candlish’s speech is first on p.247 for five pages, then William Cunningham’s is on p. 252, for three pages.
The two speeches by Cunningham and Candlish eventually gave rise to the 1851 Act of the Free Church which outlines the Free Church position on the National Covenant (1638), Solemn League and Covenant (1643) and the Revolution Settlement of 1689. The result was that the vast majority of the original Secession Church (for example, J.A. Wylie, Robert Shaw, Thomas M’Crie the younger, etc.) who came from a tradition that strongly emphasized maintaining the Scottish covenants, determined to join the Free Church.
A Layman’s Letters to the Rev. William Cunningham, 1839, three letters with two notes, 32 pages, by anonymous. Cunningham, as a professor, had written a letter to the Dean of Faculty at his college, critiquing a certain writing of his. These three layman letters publicly critique (attack) Cunningham’s letter.
These letters concern the issue of patronage (civil patrons, or magistrates, putting forward ministers to congregations in church elections), which Cunningham is against. Specifically the historic and legal warrant for patronage (or lack thereof) between the Glorious Revolution of 1689 and the official institution of patronage in Scotland in 1712 is taken up. Patronage was one of the major factors that led to the Disruption of 1843 in Scotland that gave birth to the Free Church. Here is an important window into those tumultuous years.
The major life of Cunningham, written by later prominent Free Churchmen