For more great commentaries on 1 John check:
Commentaries on All the Letters of John, Commentaries on the General Epistles, Commentaries on All the Epistles, Commentaries on the Whole New Testament
& Whole Bible Commentaries
Order of Contents
The Best Commentaries on 1 John
Calvin, John – Commentary on 1 John
*** – Spurgeon
Cotton, John – A Practical Commentary, or an Exposition with Observations, Reasons & Uses upon the First Epistle General of John EEBO (1652) 431 pp.
*** “Calamy puts his imprimatur upon this book, and speaks of the author’s name as ‘deservedly precious among the saints of God.’ In doctrine and experience he is a noble teacher.”
“A Puritan work first published in 1657. So extensive that the reader can virtually develop a systematic theology from its contents.” – Cyril J. Barber
Candlish was a leader in the Free Church of Scotland.
*** “We set great store by these lectures. A man hardly needs anything beyond Candlish. He is devout, candid, prudent and forcible.” – Spurgeon
Morgan, James – Exposition of 1 John (1866) 540 pp.
Morgan (1799–1873) was an Irish presbyterian minister in Belfast. He was a joint editor of ‘The Orthodox Presbyterian’ and was known for, amongst other writings, his exposition of the 51st Psalm, ‘The Penitent’.
*** “Dr. Candlish says that this is a work ‘of great practical interest and value,’ and that had it appeared at an earlier date, ‘he might have abstained from issuing’ his own lectures on this Epistle. We are glad to possess both works.” – Spurgeon
Pierce (1746–1829) was an English, calvinistic baptist.
*** “This devout author was highly Calvinistic, but withal full of spiritual power and unction. He loved the deep things of God, and wrote upon them in a gracious manner.” – Spurgeon
Stock, John – Exposition of 1 John (1865) 480 pp.
*** “Written by a well-instructed man of God. For spiritual teaching the work is second to none. Dr. Candlish prized it greatly.”
Commentaries on 1 John
Tyndale, William – The Exposition of the First Epistle of St. John no ToC in Expositions & Notes on Sundry Portions of the Holy Scriptures… (d. 1536; Cambridge: Parker Society, 1849), pp. 145-226
Perkins, William – The First Epistle of John in the Form of a Dialogue Between John & the Church in A Case of Conscience Resolved in Works, vol. 1 (of 3)
Law, Robert – The Tests of Life: a Study of the First Epistle of St. John (1909) 450 pp. being the Kerr Lectures for 1909 Reprinted by Baker in the Thornapple Commentary series. Has some untranslated Greek words in the main part of the text.
Law was a minister in Edinburgh, Scotland.
“Out of print and unobtainable for nearly sixty years, this unique contribution covers a major portion of the first epistle, provides timely discussion on theological and Christological themes, and includes the doctrine of sin, the account of propitiation, and the tests of righteousness, love and belief.” – Cyril J. Barber
Neander, J.A.W. – The First Epistle of John Practically Explained (1852)
Neander was a German liberal, church historian.
** “Mrs. Conant in her preface says: ‘The treasures of genius and learning which enrich his more scientific works, here seem vivified by a new element, and melt, under the fervor of his inner spiritual life, into a glowing stream of eloquent practical instruction.'” – Spurgeon
Patterson, Alexander S. – Commentaries, Expository & Practical, on the First Epistle of Paul to the Thessalonians, the Epistle of James, & the First Epistle of John (1857)
Patterson was a minister in the Free Church of Scotland.
** “Notes of discourses, with much in them. Hints may be gleaned here in abundance by students who open their eyes.” – Spurgeon
Clark is usually a good commentator, but here advocates for his unique tenets of Sandemanianism (that faith consists only of comprehension and assent, and not trust) and a Scripturalist epistemology (that one can only know the contents of Scripture and what is necessarily derived therefrom).
Graham, W. – The Spirit of Love, or a Practical & Exegetical Commentary on 1 John (1857) 400 pp.
The work originated as lectures in the German city of Bonn.
** “Graham is sound and vigorous, and does not mince matters in dealing with semi-skeptics; hence he brings upon himself violent reviews from opponents. The Literary Churchman denounces his book as containing ‘controversy without argument, criticism without proof, citation without reference, a show of scholarship without the fruits of it, and denunciation without decorum.’ To say the least of it, this review is far too severe.” – Spurgeon
Lias, John James – The First Epistle of St. John, with Exposition and Homiletical Treatment (1887) 448 pp. This was reprinted by Klock & Klock. Has some untranslated Greek words in the main part of the text.
Lias was an Anglican.
“A conservative and scholarly exposition defending the genuineness of the epistle and containing some valuable exegetical insights.” – Cyril J. Barber
The Early Church on 1 John
Clement of Alexandria – On 1 John at Patristic Bible Commentary
Clement (c. 150 – c. 215)
Homilies on the First Epistle of John in Homilies on the Gospel according to St. John & his First Epistle… (Oxford: John Henry Parker, 1849), vol. 2, pp. 1091-1246 Also in NPNF1, vol. 7
Sermons on Selected Lessons of the New Testament by S. Augustine in A Library of Fathers of the Holy Catholic Church (Oxford: John Henry Parker, 1839), pp. 947-68
The Ordinary Gloss
at Patristic Bible Commentary
Glossa Ordinaria on 1 John trans. Sarah Van Der Pas
Bede – Commentary on the Seven Catholic Epistles Ref (Cistercian Publications, 1985) 284 pp.
Bede (672/3 – 735)
On 1 John Generally
Lloyd-Jones – Life in Christ: Studies in 1 John, 4 vols. (Crossway, 1993)
vol. 1, Fellowship with God
vol. 2, Walking with God
vol. 3, Children of God
vol. 4, The Love of God
vol. 5, Life in God
On Chapters in 1 John
1 John 1-2
Binning, Hugh – Fellowship with God, or, 28 Sermons on 1 John 1 & 2:1-3, wherein the True Ground & Foundation of Attaining, the Spiritual Way of Entertaining Fellowship with the Father & the Son & the blessed condition of such as attain to it, are most succinctly & dilucidly explained (1653) in Works, p. 271 ff.
Binning was a Scottish covenanter.
*** “Milk for babes, and meat for men; calls to backsliders, and comforts for mourners. ‘There is no speaking,’ says Durham, ‘after Mr. Binning; truly he had the tongue of the learned, and knew how to speak a word in season.” – Spurgeon
Hardy, Nathanael – The First General Epistle of St. John Unfolded & Applied (d. 1670) 385 pp. This is only on the first two chapters only, being 59 sermons.
Hardy (1618-70) was reformed and was a puritan.
*** “The Editor of Nichol’s Edition says, ‘This Exposition is only a fragment. It was intended to consist of five parts, corresponding generally with the five chapters of the Epistle; but only two of them were accomplished. In matter, the sermons are purely evangelical; in spirit, they are earnest and affectionate; in manner, they are eloquent and impressive.’ This is rather too ardent a commendation.” – Spurgeon
Anonymous – Apostolic Instruction, Exemplified in the First Epistle of John (1840) This is upon the first two chapters only.
*** “Upon two chapters only, but thoroughly good, and full of sweetness and light.” – Spurgeon
1 John 3
1 John 5
John’s “gospel and first epistle, taken together, make a good apologetical manual. His epistle gives the philosophy of the gospel.”
John ‘Rabbi’ Duncan